Skip to content

news

Yorgen Fenech Seeks Chief Justice Recusal in Caruana Galizia Murder Appeal

Yorgen Fenech has asked Chief Justice Mark Chetcuti to recuse himself from hearing the state's appeal against Fenech's acquittal in the Daphne Caruana Galizia murder case, a request the Attorney General's office has opposed.

Yorgen Fenech, who was acquitted in September following a 55-day jury trial over the 2017 murder of journalist Daphne Caruana Galizia, has formally requested that Chief Justice Mark Chetcuti step aside from hearing the state's appeal against that acquittal.

Fenech's legal team argues that the Chief Justice previously presided over a Constitutional Court judgment in which he ruled on matters central to the defence, including the credibility of Assistant Commissioner Keith Arnaud and the conduct of the police investigation. The defence also contends that the judgment justified decisions made during the investigation into Keith Schembri, a figure they argue was afforded preferential treatment, with key evidence allegedly lost from his Castille office.

The prosecution, representing the Attorney General, has opposed the request. Lawyers argued that the defence misrepresented the Constitutional Court judgment by omitting sections where the court acknowledged shortcomings in the investigation.

They also cautioned that recusal cannot be used as a mechanism to influence which court hears a case, describing such use as an abuse of judicial process.

Yorgen Fenech Seeks Chief Justice Recusal in Caruana Galizia Murder Appeal

Playing it here loads it from Instagram, which lets Meta see that you visited. Open it on Instagram instead and nothing loads here.